02 September 2023
| 16:00 |
Leatherhead FC 
0 - 0
Horsham FC 
|
05 September 2023
| 20:45 |
Horsham FC
0 - 0
Leatherhead FC
|
16 September 2023
| 16:00 |
Horsham FC
2 - 2
Marlow FC 
|
19 September 2023
| 20:45 |
Marlow FC
0 - 0
Horsham FC
|
14 Oktober 2023
| 16:00 |
Horsham FC
2 - 0
Dorking Wanderers FC 
|
03 November 2023
| 20:45 |
Barnsley FC 
3 - 3
Horsham FC
|
14 November 2023
| 20:30 |
Horsham FC
0 - 3
Barnsley FC
|
02 December 2023
| 16:00 |
Sutton United FC 
3 - 0
Horsham FC
|