14 Oktober 2023
| 16:00 |
York City FC 
0 - 0
Needham Market FC 
|
17 Oktober 2023
| 20:45 |
Needham Market FC
0 - 1
York City FC
|
04 November 2023
| 16:00 |
Chester FC 
0 - 0
York City FC
|
14 November 2023
| 20:45 |
York City FC
2 - 1
Chester FC
|
01 December 2023
| 20:45 |
York City FC
0 - 1
Wigan Athletic FC 
|