02 Juli 2023
| 01:30 |
CF Montréal 
0 - 1
New York City FC 
|
06 Juli 2023
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
1 - 1
Charlotte FC 
|
09 Juli 2023
| 01:30 |
Columbus Crew 
1 - 1
New York City FC
|
16 Juli 2023
| 01:30 |
Philadelphia Union 
2 - 1
New York City FC
|
21 Augustus 2023
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
0 - 2
Minnesota United FC 
|
27 Augustus 2023
| 01:30 |
FC Cincinnati 
3 - 0
New York City FC
|
31 Augustus 2023
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 0
CF Montréal
|
02 September 2023
| 21:30 |
New York City FC
1 - 1
Vancouver Whitecaps FC 
|
16 September 2023
| 21:30 |
New York City FC
0 - 0
New York Red Bulls 
|
21 September 2023
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 0
Orlando City SC 
|
24 September 2023
| 19:00 |
New York City FC
3 - 0
Toronto FC 
|
01 Oktober 2023
| 01:30 |
Inter Miami CF 
1 - 1
New York City FC
|
08 Oktober 2023
| 01:30 |
D.C. United SC 
2 - 0
New York City FC
|
22 Oktober 2023
| 00:00 |
New York City FC
1 - 0
Chicago Fire FC 
|
25 Februari 2024
| 01:30 |
Charlotte FC
1 - 0
New York City FC
|
03 Maart 2024
| 02:30 |
St. Louis City SC 
2 - 0
New York City FC
|
09 Maart 2024
| 20:00 |
New York City FC
1 - 2
Portland Timbers 
|
17 Maart 2024
| 00:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 1
Toronto FC
|
24 Maart 2024
| 00:30 |
FC Cincinnati
1 - 0
New York City FC
|
31 Maart 2024
| 00:30 |
Inter Miami CF
1 - 1
New York City FC
|
07 April 2024
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
1 - 1
Atlanta United FC 
|
14 April 2024
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 0
New England Revolution 
|
21 April 2024
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 0
D.C. United SC
|
28 April 2024
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 1
Charlotte FC
|
05 Mei 2024
| 22:00 |
New York City FC
0 - 1
Colorado Rapids SC 
|
12 Mei 2024
| 01:30 |
Toronto FC
2 - 3
New York City FC
|
16 Mei 2024
| 01:30 |
Philadelphia Union
1 - 2
New York City FC
|
19 Mei 2024
| 01:30 |
New York City FC
2 - 1
New York Red Bulls
|