04 November 2023
| 16:00 |
Scarborough Athletic FC 
1 - 1
Forest Green Rovers FC 
|
14 November 2023
| 20:45 |
Forest Green Rovers FC
5 - 2
Scarborough Athletic FC
|
12 December 2023
| 20:45 |
Scarborough Athletic FC
2 - 4
Forest Green Rovers FC
|
19 December 2023
| 20:45 |
Blackpool FC 
3 - 0
Forest Green Rovers FC
|